« Notable Seventh Circuit opinion reversing (on procedural grounds) long drug courier sentence | Main | Potent dissent from the Sixth Circuit's denial of en banc review in Kentucky capital habeas case »
October 14, 2010
New York gets a permanant commission to help with sentencing "mess"
As reported in this New York Daily News article, which is headlined "Blue-ribbon panel commissioned to examine New York's sentencing laws," the Empire State has a new sentencing institution. Here are the particulars:
A blue-ribbon panel headed by a Brooklyn judge and Manhattan's top prosecutor aims to clean up New York's "confounding" sentencing laws. "The present sentencing laws are a mess," Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman told the Daily News. "They're like a hodgepodge with no rhyme or reason."
Lippman has called on a group of high-powered judges, defense lawyers and crime victims to carry out what he said will be the most far-reaching analysis of state sentences in 40 years. Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. and Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Barry Kamins are in charge of the Permanent Sentencing Commission for New York State....
One of its missions is to find out whether sentences being meted by the state's judges serve as a useful deterrent to future crimes. "We don't know whether the offenders are prepared to live useful lives," Lippman said. "Are sentences too long or too short?"
"Four decades after most of our sentencing laws were passed, it's time for New York to focus on being smart on crime," Vance said. "This will mean longer sentences in some instances, while in others identifying appropriate cases for alternatives to incarceration," he said.
The panel also will look into whether alternative sentences can reduce the number of defendants sent off to state prisons.... Lippman said he hopes the panel will come up with a series of recommendations that can be presented to state lawmakers.
This press release reports on other members of the new commission.
October 14, 2010 at 07:37 AM | Permalink
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference New York gets a permanant commission to help with sentencing "mess":
John Jay is the only place where these issues are scientifically and logically discussed.
Posted by: MARK | Oct 14, 2010 9:22:19 AM