« Blagojevich sentencing and the failings (and limits?) of the federal sentencing guidelines | Main | New corrections report from Minnesota shows positive impact of positive visits »

December 6, 2011

"Innocence Commissions and the Future of Post-Conviction Review"

The title of this post is the title of this newly revised paper on SSRN authored by Professor David Wolitz. Here is the abstract:

In the fall of 2006, North Carolina became the first state to establish an innocence commission — a state institution with the power to review and investigate individual post-conviction claims of actual innocence.  And on February 17, 2010, after spending seventeen years in prison for a murder he did not commit, Greg Taylor became the first person exonerated through the innocence commission process.  This article argues that the innocence commission model pioneered by North Carolina has proven itself to be a major institutional improvement over conventional post-conviction review.

The article explains why existing court-based procedures are inadequate to address collateral claims of actual innocence and why innocence commissions, due to their independent investigatory powers, are better suited to reviewing such claims. While critics on the Right claim that additional review mechanisms are unnecessary or too costly, and critics on the Left continue to push for a court-based right to innocence review, the commission model offers a compromise that fairly balances the values of both finality and accuracy in the criminal justice system.

At the same time, I argue, the North Carolina commission suffers from the tension – inherent in all expert agencies — between efficiency and discretion, on the one hand, and procedural fairness and accountability, on the other. I offer several suggestions for reform of commission procedures to help insure that none of these values is overwhelmed by the others.  Overall, the record of the North Carolina commission demonstrates that the commission approach can provide justice where the traditional court system has failed, and, with the reforms I suggest here, it ought to be a model for states across the country.

December 6, 2011 at 10:16 AM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451574769e20162fd6f9c8e970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Innocence Commissions and the Future of Post-Conviction Review" :

Comments

I've come to believe reformers make better use of their time attempting to improve those "inadequate" court-based procedures than pursuing the innocence commission strategy.

Much like civilian review boards for police, innocence commissions sound good but haven't functioned well because they're always hamstrung in the creation by special interests who oppose their fundamental mission. Good idea in theory, perhaps, but in practice almost all postconviction relief happens via habeas writs in traditional courts, and that will continue to be the case for a long time. IMO it's more effective to focus time and resources on improving those processes to better accommodate actual-innocence claims than creating a new layer of government bureaucracy that's unlikely to work well.

Posted by: Gritsforbreakfast | Dec 6, 2011 11:12:53 AM

Beats By Dre USCarmelo Anthony From the New York KnicksCheap Beats By DreKobe Bryant From the Los Angeles LakersBeats By Dre SaleLeBron James From the Miami HeatBeats By Dre HeadphonesDwyane Wade From the Miami Heatdr dre headphonesTracy McGrady From the Atlanta Hawksbeats by dr dre headphonesYao Ming From the Houston Rocketsdr dre studio headphonesYi Jianlian From the Washington Wizardsbeats by dr dre pro headphonesChris Paul From the Los Angeles Clippersbeats by dr dre solo HDKevin Durant From the Oklahoma City Thundernew style beats by dr dreDirk Nowitzki From the Dallas MavericksCasque Dr DreJason Kidd From the Dallas MavericksBeats By DreTim Duncan From the San Antonio SpursCasque Monster BeatsDeron Williams From the New Jersey NetsDr.Dre OutletDwight Howard From the Orlando Magiccasque dr dre beatsKevin Garnett From the Boston Celticscasques beats by dre studioPaul Pierce From the Boston Celticscasque beats by dr dre proRay Allen From the Boston Celticscasque beats by dr dre solo HDDerrick Rose From the Chicago Bullscasque dr dre beatsLuis Scola From the Houston Rocketscasque beats by dreKevin Lowry From the Houston Rocketsfrance beats by dreChuck Hayes From the Sacramento kingsbeats by dreAllen Iverson 76 people from Philadelphiadr dre casqueAllen Brooks From the Phoenix Sunscasque beats by dr dreCarl Landry From the New Orleans Hornetscasque beats studioSteve Nash From the Phoenix Sunscasque beats proTony Parker From the San Antonio Spurscasque beats soloManu Ginobili From the San Antonio Spurscasques dr dre solo HDMarc Gasol From the Memphis GrizzliesBeats By Dre AustraliaPau Gasol From the Los Angeles LakersBeats By Dr DreLol Deng From the Chicago BullsDr Dre BeatsDanny Granger From the Indiana pacersDr Dre HeadphonesRussell Westbrook From the Oklahoma City ThunderAustralia beats by dre headphonesLaMarcus Aldridge From the Portland Trail BlazersAustralia beats studioRudy Gay From the Memphis Grizzliesbeats by dre pro headphonsMike Conley From the Memphis Grizzliesdr dre solo HDZach Randolph From the Memphis GrizzliesBeats By Dr DreKevin Martin From the Houston RocketsBeats By Dre AustraliaCourtney Lee From the Houston RocketsBeats By Dre HeadphonesLamar Odom From the Dallas MavericksDr Dre Headphones AustraliaShawn Marion From the Dallas MavericksBeats By Dre HeadphonesRudy Fernandez From the Dallas MavericksBeats By Dr Dre Studio HeadphonesRichard Jefferson From the San Antonio SpursBeats By Dr Dre Pro HeadphonesRajon Rondo From the Boston CelticsBeats By Dr Dre Solo HeadphonesJermaine ONeal From the Boston CelticsBeats By Dr Dre Solo HD HeadphonesAmare Stoudemire From the New York Knicksdr dre beats HeadphonesChauncey Billups From the Los Angeles ClippersBeats By Dre UKElton Brand 76 people from PhiladelphiaDiscount Beats By Dr DreAndre Iguodala 76 people from PhiladelphiaDr Dre Headphones UKEvan Turner 76 people from PhiladelphiaBeats By Dre Online StoreAntawn Jamison From the Cleveland Cavaliersbeats by dreKyrie Irving From the Cleveland Cavaliersdre beats headphonesRashard Lewis From the Washington Wizards New Arrival Beats By Dr DreAndray Blatche From the Washington WizardsBeats By Dr StudioJohn Wall From the Washington Wizardsdr dre Studio headphonesJaVale McGee From the Washington WizardsBeats By Dr Dre ProJosh Howard From the Washington WizardsBeats Pro HeadphonesGilbert Arenas From the Orlando Magicbeats by dre soloHedo Turkoglu From the Orlando Magicbeats by dre solo HDJoe Johnson From the Atlanta Hawksbeats solo HD headphonesJosh Smith From the Atlanta Hawksjustbeats headphonesAl Horford From the Atlanta Hawksdiscount beats headphonesDavid Lee From the Golden State Warriorscanada gooseMonta Ellis From the Golden State Warriorscanada goose ukMarcus Camby From the Portland Trail Blazerscanada goose parkaGerald Wallace From the Portland Trail Blazerscanada goose outletRaymond Felton From the Portland Trail Blazerscanada goose jacketsJonny Flynn From the Houston Rockets

Posted by: Beats By Dre | Feb 2, 2012 3:57:03 AM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB