« You be the judge: what sentence would you impose on 15-year-old child killer? | Main | Two diverse state prison stories provide would-be reformers "follow-the-money" lessons »

February 8, 2012

"Pain, Love, and Voice: The Role of Domestic Violence Victims in Sentencing"

The title of this post is the headline of this new piece from Hadar Dancig-Rosenberg and Dana Pugach, which in now available via SSRN. Here is the abstract:

Should the victim of a domestic crime be entitled to express her views and concerns when her violent spouse is being sentenced, even if her request is for leniency?  This may well be the most difficult question for supporters of victims' rights, who are accustomed to relate to victims who ask for severe sentences for their assailants.  This question is affected by the complicated conflicting interests at the sentencing stage.  The harm suffered by the victim of an offense is pitched against the personal profile of the assailant and the public interest.

This article seeks not only to confront this issue but also to suggest a progressive resolution model, based on firm ground.  At the base is a unique interpretation and application of an expressive theory of criminal justice.  It is then supported by a complex feminist view and psycho-social research that will be used to highlight the flexibility required of any suggested solution.  This uniqueness will be explained by the characteristic dynamics of a violent relationship and the inherent differences between the women being discussed and the abstract category of 'classic (female) victims' asking for harsh sentences to be imposed on their attackers.

The article not only challenges sentencing theorists and supporters of 'classical' criminal law theory but also certain feminist theories, as it analyzes these issues from the perspective of conflicting theories, paternalism versus autonomy, and asserts their inadequacy in this case.  The authors call for the adoption of a complex feminist view instead of the dichotomous understanding of the autonomy-paternalism tension.  This argument necessitates a resolution-sensitive model that recognizes the variety of situations reflecting the actions of women living in the shadow of violence and functioning from a position of partial autonomy.  A development of a multi-dimensional model that recognizes the plurality of female typology is essential in order to best serve this multifaceted victims' rights theory.  The article then translates the theory into practice and suggests using Victim Reports as a means of empowering the women, hearing their authentic voices, enriching the Criminal Justice System and, potentially, even advancing the study of violence.

Though this piece provides a distinctively gendered perspective on victims' rights at sentencing, I believe it taps into some important broader themes.  Just as every criminal offender has distinct and dynamic characteristics than will be effected by various punishment options in distinct and dynamic ways, so too do victims often have distinct and dynamic characteristics that call for sophisticated and nuanced sentencing laws and practices in order to best serve their diverse interests in different cases.

February 8, 2012 at 10:26 AM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451574769e20168e6fb97bc970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Pain, Love, and Voice: The Role of Domestic Violence Victims in Sentencing":

Comments

Yes, a victim should be able to express views and concerns when her loved-one is being sentenced for violence. A well informed sentencing committee will listern, and pay careful attention to the enotions. Of course, the victims need counseling also, from professions. I am a student at University of Houston - Downtown.

Posted by: Virginia Phillips | Feb 8, 2012 4:58:43 PM

There is lots of criminal justice colleges in NJ designed for all those career seekers who are fond of selecting the criminal justice college rather than falling for the typical law schools in New Jersey. Enrolling in some law school was surely a ticket to achieve excellence in this field in the past but now the trend is very much different all around.

Posted by: daniel | Apr 16, 2012 11:09:41 AM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB