« Noting the shame of prison rape in incarceration nation | Main | More evidence of the sad perversity of California's administration of the death penalty »

October 6, 2013

"Should Paris Hilton Receive a Lighter Prison Sentence Because She's Rich? Evidence from a Survey Experiment"

The title of this post is the title of this intriguing article now available via SSRN authored by Josef Montag and Tomáš Sobek.  Here is the abstract:

Different people experience the same punishment in with differing intensity. Some legal scholars are proposing that improving scientific knowledge and progressing technologies, such as fMRI, need and should be incorporated in our penal systems.  This would facilitate calibrating the punishment not only to the crime but also to the offender’s persona, so that different people experience the same punishment for the same crime.  However, such a substantial change in the criminal law and policy requires legitimacy and popular approval.

We run a simple pilot experiment in order to ascertain whether such approval is in sight. We found that it may be in the case of pecuniary punishments.  With regard to incarceration policies, however, the possibility of popular acceptance of such changes seems remote.  This finding presents a potential challenge to the literature and may complicate the implementation of suggested reforms.  We aim to extend our study to investigate the factors behind this divergence and to check robustness of our experiments in Germany and the US.

October 6, 2013 at 10:42 AM | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Should Paris Hilton Receive a Lighter Prison Sentence Because She's Rich? Evidence from a Survey Experiment":


Q. “Should … ?”

Posted by: Just Plain Jim (Just Another Guy) | Oct 7, 2013 8:57:42 AM

I can't see this working, how would we know if the punishment truly matches their persona. There are too many variables at play.

Posted by: Adam | Oct 7, 2013 3:12:14 PM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB