« Ohio completes execution using novel two-drug lethal injection protocol... UPDATED with media reports of problems | Main | Notable new research from Pew about the success of parole in New Jersey »

January 16, 2014

"If You Ain't in Prison, You Just Got Lucky: Luck, Culpability, and the Retributivist Justification of Punishment"

The title of this post is the title of this new paper by Kenneth Einar Himma now available via SSRN. Here is the abstract:

Thomas Nagel argues that the pervasive role that luck plays in conditioning behavior seems inconsistent with ordinary views about moral accountability and culpability.  As many criminal justice practices seem to rely on these ordinary views, the pervasiveness of luck also seems inconsistent with the legitimacy of a number of criminal law practices.  For example, the claim that people do not have direct control over the consequences of their acts and hence that the consequences of an act are conditioned by luck calls into question the legitimacy of the traditional practice of punishing unsuccessful attempts less severely than successful attempts; if the only difference between a successful and unsuccessful attempt is a matter of luck, then there can be no difference, other things being equal, in culpability between the two.

In this essay, I argue that the pervasive role that luck plays in conditioning a person’s acts calls into question the viability of retributivist justifications of punishment, which hold that punishment is justified insofar as deserved.  A person is not culpable or deserving of punishment, according to ordinary views, for events beyond her control.  But if the factors conditioning an agent’s act are all matters of luck beyond the agent’s control, then she is not deserving of punishment for the act.  The pervasiveness of such luck seems inconsistent with retributivism and threatens not only differential punishment for successful and unsuccessful attempts.  More significantly, it calls into question the very legitimacy of punishment itself.  The problem of luck goes well beyond its implications for the law of attempts.

January 16, 2014 at 03:53 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451574769e2019b04dd14ce970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "If You Ain't in Prison, You Just Got Lucky: Luck, Culpability, and the Retributivist Justification of Punishment":

Comments

When you are itShay out of luck, you are out of luck.

Posted by: Liberty1st | Jan 17, 2014 8:29:34 AM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB