« "Harsh Sentencing, Overstuffed Prisons — It's Time for Reform" | Main | Should those who really favor gun rights protest the right to sell and own a safer gun? »

May 4, 2014

"Criminals Get All the Rights: The Sociolegal Construction of Different Rights to Die"

The title of this post is the title of this intriguing new article available via SSRN authored by Meredith Martin Rountree.  Here is the abstract:

In the United States, different people have different rights to die. After sketching the legal standards for hastening death, this article uses empirical research on “volunteers,” death-sentenced prisoners who hastened execution by dropping their appeals, to argue for integrating into adjudications of requests to hasten execution a Fourteenth Amendment analysis comparable to that used in medical cases.

The article discusses socio-legal influences contributing to death-sentenced prisoners’ simultaneously more expansive and less protective right to assistance in dying. Further, it contends that death-sentenced prisoners are more successful in hastening death not simply because of their sentence, but because the law is responding to differently defined social problems. Paradoxically, in this case, the more expansive right reflects and furthers social marginalization.  In addition to raising important questions about the legitimacy of the American death penalty, the Article illuminates the different ways in which rights to accelerate death can be implemented.  In so doing, the Article contributes to the increasingly pressing political debate over ordinary Americans’ ability to end their own lives.

May 4, 2014 at 10:30 AM | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Criminals Get All the Rights: The Sociolegal Construction of Different Rights to Die":


In America one only has a right to die at the hand of another. There is no right to suicide. This makes perfect sense. The real crime in suicide is not death, it is the self-infliction. Self-inflicted death robs another human being of the pleasure of killing. Intolerable.

Posted by: Just me again | May 4, 2014 11:50:49 AM

I have to agree I've always thought the law against suicide was retarded. Basically it punishes those who FAIL to complete the crime.

As long as they don't hurt or kill anyone else. who cares!

Posted by: rodsmith | May 4, 2014 4:24:26 PM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB