« En banc Ninth Circuit concludes application of guidelines should generally be reviewed for abuse of discretion | Main | Split Sixth Circuit panel uphold injunction blocking Ohio lethal injection protocol »

April 6, 2017

Arkansas Parole Board recommends clemency for one of eight condemned scheduled for execution later this month

As reported in this AP piece, the "Arkansas Parole Board on Wednesday recommended that Gov. Asa Hutchinson alter the state's unprecedented execution schedule and grant mercy to a death row inmate who directed the torture and murder of a teenager more than two decades ago." Here is more:

Jason McGehee, 40, is one of eight inmates scheduled to die in four double executions this month. Hutchinson, who is not bound by the board's finding that McGehee should have his sentence cut to life without parole, can intervene at any time before the execution begins on April 27. The Republican governor not said when he will make a decision.

Until Wednesday, the state Parole Board had rejected every death row clemency request presented to it since 1990.

With a key lethal injection drug expiring at the end of the month, the Arkansas Department of Correction hopes to execute eight men in a 10-day period beginning April 17. Only Texas has executed that many inmates in a month, doing it twice in 1997. Seven executions in a month would still be a record for Arkansas.

Prosecutors say McGehee, who had just turned 20, directed the fatal assault of Johnny Melbourne Jr., a 15-year-old who had told police about a northern Arkansas theft ring. In voting 6-1 in favor of McGehee's clemency request, the Parole Board considered letters and testimony from the judge from McGehee's trial, a former Correction Department chief, members of McGehee's family and the victim's father.

"The death of John Melbourne, Jr. was the tragic result of a group-dynamic gone wrong," retired Circuit Judge Robert McCorkindale wrote, according to documents released by the state Parole Board. McGehee was one of several people who participated in the attack, but was the only defendant sentenced to death, and the retired judge called it "an excessive punishment."

Former Department of Correction Director Ray Hobbs told the panel at a 40-minute hearing Friday that McGehee had become a model prisoner. "He still has value that can be given to others if his life is spared," Hobbs said.

Linda Christensen, the inmate's aunt, said in an affidavit filed with the board that McGehee suffered psychological abuse as a teenager, such as when his stepfather killed the boy's dog after the dog fought with another dog for food. The stepfather "got up and kicked Dusty in the side with his cowboy boots as hard as he could," Christensen wrote. "He lay and suffered and the kids had to watch him die slowly. ... Jason was never the same after that."

Melbourne's father had asked the board to reject McGehee's clemency request. "John didn't have this. Even though he was begging for his life and was hurting. He didn't have this and he begged for his life too. He didn't have y'all," the elder Melbourne said.

Board Chairman John Felts voted against clemency. He said McGehee's death sentence wasn't excessive considering the inmate had orchestrated the Aug. 19, 1996, attack. The boy was beaten and tortured at a house in Harrison, then bound and driven to an abandoned farmhouse outside Omaha, a town in northern Arkansas. He was later strangled while his hands were tied with an electrical cord.

April 6, 2017 at 08:55 AM | Permalink


Sickening advocacy for murdering torturer by anti-victim lawyer reptiles.

Posted by: David Behar | Apr 6, 2017 11:03:22 AM

Let's hope that the Arkansas governor stays strong. This was a vicious crime, and the punishment is richly deserved. What wusses on the Parole Board.

Posted by: federalist | Apr 6, 2017 11:30:55 AM

Breaking news: COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — US appeals court rejects Ohio's new 3-drug lethal injection process, casting doubt on executions this year.

Posted by: Joe | Apr 6, 2017 11:58:09 AM

Thanks for flagging Sixth Cir ruling, Joe. Will blog after an ongoing faculty meeting.

Posted by: Doug B. | Apr 6, 2017 1:19:34 PM

Re: Ohio--'rat judging.

Posted by: federalist | Apr 6, 2017 1:29:47 PM

Is it not high time to impeach judges for their decisions? They do not know anything.

Congratulations to all the rent seeking, anti-victim weasels here.

Joe needs to disclose the fraction of his income from government.b

Posted by: David Behar | Apr 6, 2017 3:35:57 PM

I did my taxes already.

Posted by: Joe | Apr 6, 2017 4:23:17 PM

Joe. Please, tell the class the fraction of your income that comes from government. Accept, embrace your inner rent seeking weasel.

Posted by: David Behar | Apr 7, 2017 1:38:31 PM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB