January 8, 2018
Interesting comments on reform and rehabilitation from Deputy AG Rosenstein
Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein today delivered these lengthy remarks at the American Correctional Association's Winter Conference. Folks interested in prison policies and practices, as well as the messages being delivered by the US Justice Department these days, should make time to read the entire speech. And sentencing fans (including students in the Sentencing class I start teaching today) may be especially interested in these interesting comments about reform and rehabilitation from the early part of the speech:
The American Correctional Association has a proud history of supporting the work of prison and jail officials. More than 147 years ago, in 1870, corrections officials from the United States and abroad met in Cincinnati, Ohio and adopted a “Declaration of Principles” they believed should guide the field of corrections. One of your principles is that the purpose of incarcerating criminals is “the protection of society.”
One of the most important management principles is that it is essential to articulate the big-picture goal for an organization. That vision filters down into how other managers understand their mission, and ultimately into everything that our employees do. In law enforcement, our goal is to reduce crime.
Correctional agencies play a critical role in achieving that goal. By providing inmates with structure, and teaching them discipline and skills during their incarceration, you increase the probability that they will become productive members of society and reduce the likelihood of recidivism.
When I read the original version of your principles, I noticed that the word “reform” appears 27 times. The word “rehabilitate” does not appear at all. Rehabilitation came into vogue as a sentencing goal in the 20th century. Many people ultimately concluded that rehabilitation was not a realistic goal for prisons.
After spending almost three decades in law enforcement, I agree that we need to focus on reform of criminals, not rehabilitation. The reason is that “re-habilitation,” by definition, is about restoring a person’s good reputation and ability to work.
There are some criminals for whom rehabilitation is a reasonable goal. They are people who lived law-abiding lives and were productive members of society, before something went wrong and caused them to go astray.
But many of the career criminals housed in our prisons unfortunately were not properly habilitated before they offended. The criminals who were not productive members of society need reform, not rehabilitation.
Admitting that most of our inmates need reform is not a way of disparaging the criminals. It is instead a frank way to acknowledge that our task is more than just helping them overcome a few mistakes. Many inmates do not just lack self-restraint. They lack job skills. They lack education. They lack family structure. They lack discipline.
While they are under governmental supervision, you have the chance to help them reform by imposing discipline and offering opportunities for improvement. The most important thing for many inmates to learn is the discipline of following a schedule: wake up at a particular time, report to work when required, eat meals at the designated hours, and go to bed early enough to start fresh the next morning.
Some of the programs you offer also may be useful to reform inmates and set them on the right path. Programs such as institutional work assignments, prison industries, substance abuse treatment, and educational or vocational training. Your work makes our communities safer.
The principles from 1870 also codify the professionalism that defines corrections officials. They explain that “[s]pecial training, as well as high qualities of head and heart, [are] required to make a good prison or reformatory officer.”
January 8, 2018 at 10:56 AM | Permalink
Rehab is quackery. Reform is believing in Santa Claus, and ridiculous.
For example, Rod Rosenstein is a Harvard Law School radicalized lawyer. Try to get him to support crime victim interests. You could torture him on the rack. He could not change.
He Fergusoned Baltimore. He is the ultimate mastermind behind the mass murder of hundreds of additional black males every year, since then.
Posted by: David Behar | Jan 8, 2018 4:43:57 PM