« At resentencing, former New York Assembly speaker gets (only?) seven years in federal prison for corruption | Main | State judge rejects constitutional attack on Tennessee's lethal injection protocol »
July 28, 2018
Interesting early information from the Safe Streets & Second Chances effort to take an evidence-driven approach to recidivism
In this post from January, I spotlighted the Safe Streets & Second Chances initiative which describes itself as an "an innovative program that takes an evidence-driven approach to the chronic issues of repeat offenders and recidivism, using academic research to craft individualized reentry plans that shift the ultimate measure of success from whether individuals are punished to whether these individuals are improved, rehabilitated, and capable of redemption." This new Washington Post piece, headlined "Koch network project gears up to help inmates reenter society after prison," provides an interesting update on the project:
A new project funded by the network aligned with billionaire industrialist Charles Koch is tracking and monitoring 1,100 inmates in four states after they are released from prison starting Aug. 1 to help them successfully reintegrate into society.
Through the project, called Safe Streets and Second Chances, a team of researchers from Florida State University will evaluate former inmates for 15 months after their release — a volatile period that often leads to their rearrest. The project is in its $4 million pilot phase, as researchers prepare to test the effectiveness of a new reentry model that focuses on individualized plans to help inmates find healthy coping and thinking patterns, the right employment opportunities, and positive social engagement.
For the past six months, the researchers have been interviewing the men and women in the program, who are currently housed in 48 prisons in rural and urban areas in Texas, Florida, Pennsylvania and Kentucky. They will present the early findings today in Colorado, at the twice-annual meeting of the network’s largest donors....
The network is advocating a shift in the criminal justice system toward prioritizing rehabilitation and reducing recidivism, rather than focusing on punishment. For years, the network has pushed for bipartisan support for overhauling the criminal justice system, and has teamed up with Van Jones, a former Obama administration official and CNN political commentator, for the cause....
With the research conducted through Safe Streets and Second Chances, network officials say they want to transform the way reentry programs are run in communities across the country. “What we’re trying to do is to prepare prisoners to reenter society and become productive members and taxpaying citizens, hopefully living productive lives and taking care of their families,” said Doug Deason, a Dallas businessman and Koch network donor who is on the advisory council of Safe Streets and Second Chances.
After interviewing the inmates preparing for release, researchers found these prisoners overwhelmingly felt optimistic about their chances of rehabilitation in life outside prison but generally had high levels of trauma. Nearly 70 percent of people in the program reported seeing someone seriously injured or killed. Half the inmates had seen or handled dead bodies — more than a dozen times for some male prisoners. The majority of them reported having a close friend or family member who was murdered, and 58 percent reported having a drug use disorder.
People with untreated trauma symptoms are more likely to become impulsive and incorrectly perceive threats to themselves and others, which could lead to an act of crime and recidivism, according to Carrie Pettus-Davis, a Florida State University professor and the lead researcher. It also could affect their ability to navigate the laws restricting felons from employment, housing and education opportunities, she said.
“Despite all of the positive orientations and aspirations, this population also is really dealing with some very challenging circumstances,” Pettus-Davis said. “There’s an enormous amount of trauma represented for both men and women. ... Once people become incarcerated, we need to make sure we’re appropriately responding to experiences of psychological trauma.”
Lots of information and data about and from this project can be found in this new release from Safe Streets & Second Chances under the title "New Research Shows Incarcerated Individuals Want to Be Rehabilitated and Are Hungry for Second Chances as They Reenter Society." Here are excerpts (with links from the original):
Incarcerated individuals want to be rehabilitated, are eager for a second chance, and are emotionally capable of successfully reentering society, new independent data shows.
According to statistics compiled by Florida State University (FSU) researchers, both male and female participants said they want to work more, learn more, and spend more time on personal relationships, improving their health, and practicing their faith than they currently do while incarcerated. They also reported fairly high levels of emotional well-being, suggesting that they are primed to successfully rejoin society upon their release....
According to the data, inmates want to rehabilitate themselves through work, education, and faith, and spend more time on personal relationships.
- Respondents expressed a desire to work or improve their work situation.
- Men reported working about two hours a day but said they would like to work almost four times that amount.
- Women reported working almost 1.5 hours per day but said they’d like to work over three times that amount.
- Overall, respondents said they’d like to spend twice the amount of time they currently spend on school activities.
- Both men and women said they want to devote more time to community involvement and spend twice as much time working on personal relationships.
- Both groups said they’d like to spend more time each week on spiritual or religious activities.
Next, while individuals said they had experienced a generally high level of trauma in life, they also reported a fairly high level of emotional well-being.
- Nearly 70 percent of participants said they had seen someone seriously injured or killed.
- 50 percent said they had seen dead bodies (other than at a funeral) or had to handle dead bodies. Male respondents reported experiencing this an average of over 17 times.
- Over 40 percent said they had been attacked with a gun, knife, or some other weapon by someone, including a family member or friend.
- About 57 percent said that a close friend or family member had been murdered.
- Over 32 percent of female respondents said they had been forced to have intercourse or another form of sex against their will.
- On average, females reported having experienced sexual abuse as a child 8.88 times.
- 58 percent reported having a drug use disorder, while 35 percent reported having an alcohol use disorder.
- While both men and women reported similar levels of childhood emotional abuse, they also reported fairly high levels of current emotional well-being, suggesting that they are emotionally resilient and fit to contribute to society in a positive way.
July 28, 2018 at 12:15 PM | Permalink
This was a survey of aspirations and of past trauma. Did they survey the number of crimes committed in the 15 months with a promise of confidentiality? Crime is lucrative and pleasurable. These people have better social skills than litigators. They get more people to do things for them than those lawyers.
I want to become richer, thinner, and nicer. I want to get treated for my addiction to video, one stronger than that to crack cocaine. I have seen and handled dead bodies, including those of loved ones. Yet, nothing will change about what I do every day.
Posted by: David Behar | Jul 28, 2018 12:29:05 PM