« Another major SCOTUS morning | Main | A bit of death in the afternoon »

November 7, 2005

A terrific examination of Alito and criminal law

In The National Law Journal, Marcia Coyle has this terrific and thorough article, entitled "Cutting his own path: 'Justice' Alito could alter criminal law," which explores the possible impact of Justice O'Connor's likely replacement on various criminal justice issues.  (Disclaimer:  My view of this article is heavily biased because I am quoted at length in the article and because the article begins with a reference to the latest issue of the Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law.)

The lengthy Coyne article is today's must-read for folks interested in Alito and criminal justice issues.  Here is the enticing lead to whet your appetite:

The last person with substantial hands-on prosecutorial experience to ascend to the Supreme Court was Earl Warren, whose 18 years in those trenches influenced the Warren Court's revolution in criminal procedure.  But don't expect former federal prosecutor and now Judge Samuel A. Alito, if confirmed, to steer a similar course.

The article notes that Professor Yale Kamisar has an article in the latest issue of the Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law exploring the impact of Warren's criminal justice background.  That article, "How Earl Warren's Twenty-Two Years in Law Enforcement Affected His Work as Chief Justice," is a fascinating read and can be accessed here

For anyone interested in thinking dynamically about how the new Roberts Court might approach criminal justice issues, I encourage checking out all the articles appearing in the OSJCL's symposium entitled "The Warren Court Criminal Justice Revolution: Reflections a Generation Later."  In addition to the Kamisar article, there are terrific articles from Professors Morgan Cloud, Richard Frase, Tracey Meares, Donald Dripps and George Thomas III.  Professor George Thomas merits considerable credit for organizing this symposium as a Guest Editor for the OSJCL, and his informative introductory article, "Through a Glass Darkly: Seeing the Real Warren Court Criminal Justice Legacy," can be accessed here.

November 7, 2005 at 12:10 PM | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A terrific examination of Alito and criminal law:

» Blog Round-up - Monday, November 7th from SCOTUSblog
In nomination news: Sentencing Law & Policy has this detailed post with yet more information about Alito and criminal law. Think Progress has this post titled, "What the New York Times Won’t Tell You About Alito’s ‘Apolitical’ Supporter." On FindLaw...... [Read More]

Tracked on Nov 7, 2005 10:36:10 PM


facinating information

Posted by: criminal background checks | Dec 13, 2005 5:33:05 PM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB