« Split DC Circuit panel issues important Second Amendment ruling in via Heller II | Main | New ACS issue brief on "right to counsel" cases this SCOTUS term »

October 4, 2011

Eleventh Circuit now to review en banc FSA pipeline sentencing issue

Regular readers may recall this post and this post from this past summer discussing the important Eleventh Circuit panel ruling in US v. Rojas declaring that the reduced statutory crack sentencing terms of the Fair Sentencing Act apply "to defendants who committed crack cocaine offenses before August 3, 2010, the date of its enactment, but who are sentenced thereafter."  Today, the Eleventh Circuit released this new order in Rojas indicating that this issue is now going to be examined by the full Eleventh Circuit en banc.

I am disappointed (but not all that surprised) that the full Eleventh Circuit does not have better things to do than to re-review the application of the FSA's new, more fair mandatory minimum terms to a few more federal defendants.  After all, since the Rojas ruling, both the Attorney General (as detailed here) and the Third Circuit (in Dixon discussed here) have concluded that the Rojas panel got the law right.  

Moreover, and more importantly, the Rojas panel ruling does not require that district judges give lower sentences to the most aggravated crack offenses, rather it simply allows district judges to consider lower sentences for the most mitigated crack offenses.  But, apparently a majority of judges on the Eleventh Circuit are so fearful of even giving a few more federal defendants even the chance to argue at sentencing for the lower sentences that Congress has now deemed more fair that they have to turn this into a big en banc battle.  (I wonder how much in federal tax dollars are going to be wasted on the federal criminal justice debate over this narrow issue of when exactly crack sentencing is supposed to become fair as Congress has commanded.  Yeesh.)

Some prior posts on this FSA pipeline issue:

October 4, 2011 at 12:37 PM | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Eleventh Circuit now to review en banc FSA pipeline sentencing issue:


I don't think it's as bleak a situation as you make it sound. The 11th Circuit also granted en banc review in U.S. v. Hudson today, which was decided by a different panel than Rojas and came to an opposite conclusion. Couldn't the court be taking them both to affirm the panel's ruling in Rojas, rather than overturning it?

Posted by: Paul | Oct 4, 2011 7:58:54 PM

Hope so. I envy your optimism.

Posted by: Christopher Keese | Oct 5, 2011 8:42:04 AM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB