« Notable account of all the advocacy and interests surrounding California's Prop. 47 | Main | Following-up in Maryland after court rules some sex offenders not subject to new registration requirements »

November 1, 2014

Documenting modern state investments in schools and prisons

OriginalAs reported in this Huffington Post piece, headlined "States Are Prioritizing Prisons Over Education, Budgets Show," a new analysis of state-level spending highlights that states have devoted taxpayer resources in recent years a lot more to prisons relative to schools. Here are the basics from a new report via the HuffPost's summary:

If state budget trends reflect the country's policy priorities, then the U.S. currently values prisoners over children, a new report suggests.

A report released this week by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities shows that the growth of state spending on prisons in recent years has far outpaced the growth of spending on education. After adjusting for inflation, state general fund spending on prison-related expenses increased over 140 percent between 1986 and 2013. During the same period, state spending on K-12 education increased only 69 percent, while higher education saw an increase of less than six percent.

State spending on corrections has exploded in recent years, as incarceration rates have more than tripled in a majority of states in the past few decades. The report says that the likelihood that an offender will be incarcerated has gone up across the board for all major crimes. At the same time, increases in education spending have not kept pace. In fact, since 2008, spending on education has actually declined in a majority of states in the wake of the Great Recession....

Michael Mitchell, a co-author of the report and a policy analyst with the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, suggested that education spending could actually help lower incarceration rates. “When you look at prisoners, people who get sent to prison and their educational levels, [the levels are] typically much lower than individuals who are not sent to prison," he told The Huffington Post. “Being a high school dropout dramatically increases your likelihood of being sent to prison.”

“Spending so many dollars locking up so many people, those are dollars that inevitably cannot be used to provide pre-K slots … or financial aid for those who want to go to college,” Mitchell added.

The report suggests that states' spending practices are ultimately harming their economies, while not making the states especially safer. The authors ultimately conclude that if “states were still spending the same amount on corrections as they did in the mid-1980s, adjusted for inflation, they would have about $28 billion more available each year for education and other productive investments.”

“The types of investments to help people out of poverty and break that school-to-prison pipeline are investments in early education, helping youth stay in school and getting them college campuses,” said Mitchell.

The full 21-page report from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, titled "Changing Priorities: State Criminal Justice Reforms and Investments in Education," can be accessed at this link.

November 1, 2014 at 02:40 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451574769e201b8d0888b66970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Documenting modern state investments in schools and prisons :

Comments

The Kissinger lie meter is spinning at supersonic speed.

Criminals do not specialize. If you lock them up fewer children will be abused in every way.

While the chances of incarceration have increased, there is still an order of magnitude difference between the chance of being crime victim and incarceration, with 20 million Index felonies and 2 million prosecution. Because safety is Job One and Job Last for government, a wholly owned subsidiary of the criminal cult enterprise that makes the lawyer profession, it is in utter failure. Imagine a car mechanic with this record. Only 1 in 10 broken cars are fixed. Of those fixed, 1 in 5 gets a wrong repair or never needed one. That mechanic would get arrested as a threat to public safety. The lawyer hierarchy deserves no less.

It fails to say that the return on investment for prison is likely 100 to one, or even 1000 to one counting the ultra-violent offspring not spawned by the criminal and his crack whores. What is the return on investment of an American education? It has been destroyed by the lawyer always attacking teachers on the slightest pretextual gotcha, and empowering horribly entitled parents, and their monstrous spawn.

I would support a direct action arm of the PTA visiting these awful judges, and applying the lash. Tie them to the tree outside the courthouse. To deter. This judge enemy must be stopped. Killing them is not an answer because they would be replaced by endless parade of like minded internal betrayers. No, they must be deterred specifically.Use the lash. It works. Prosecutors protect criminals, because the criminal generates stupid government make work jobs for the lawyer.

The article assumes that education prevents crime, stating dropping out increases its risk. Perhaps they dropped out because, as Bill Gates did, they learned time is money. Their criminal enterprises may have been too lucrative and each day in school cost them a $1000 in profits.

I cannot take the spinning meter anymore, and may continue later.

Posted by: Supremacy Claus | Nov 1, 2014 9:00:10 PM

Repeal CAPTA and more fathers will be with their children and not in prison. Stop the welfare, more families will stick together. Let states run their schools and decide what is best for their community. A blanket policy cannot provide a solution for everybody, different states have different needs! CLOSE THE BORDERS until we the people can fix our own country.


Texian National

Posted by: LC in Texas | Nov 2, 2014 6:17:18 PM

That's really interesting. Of course, it's really difficult to quantify exactly what impact this spending disparity has on the entire economy, and how different things would be if that spending growth was flipped around. But, if increased spending on education results in lower crime rates, and we could channel some of our prison spending into education, then it seems like the economic benefits could be significantly more than just having a cheaper prison system. With more people out of prisons and in productive roles within society, the economic and societal benefits would be huge.

Posted by: Jason Manion | Nov 3, 2014 3:46:06 PM

This is very educative. In my country, Nigeria, though the budget for schools( ie, education)is still very low when compared with the population, it is still much more than that for the prisons.

Posted by: Onyii Nwosu-Igbo | Jun 11, 2015 2:26:44 AM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB