« Notable reactions and commentary after Pope Francis calls again for death penalty abolition | Main | Depressing new 2005 released-prisoner recidivism data from BJS (with lots of spin possibiities) »
September 25, 2015
How might House speaker John Boehner's resignation announcement impact prospects for federal sentencing reform?
The question in the title of this post was my first reaction to this remarkable and unexpected news via Politico:
Speaker John Boehner, who rose from bartender's son to the most powerful man in Congress, will retire at the end of October, ending a tumultuous five-year tenure atop the House of Representatives.
Boehner, 65, planned to leave Congress at the end of 2014, one of his aides said Friday morning, but returned because of the unexpected defeat of Eric Cantor.
"The Speaker believes putting members through prolonged leadership turmoil would do irreparable damage to the institution," the Boehner aide said. "He is proud of what this majority has accomplished, and his speakership, but for the good of the Republican Conference and the institution, he will resign the Speakership and his seat in Congress, effective October 30."...
Boehner came into power on the power of the 2010 tea party wave, but it was that movement that gave him the most problems. Boehner's tenure will be remembered for his internal political battles, but also his complicated relationship with President Barack Obama. He and Obama tried — but repeatedly failed — to cut a deal on a massive fiscal agreement. But Boehner has had some significant victories, including the free-trade deal that Congress passed this year, and changes to entitlement systems....
Boehner's decision, relayed in a closed Republican meeting Friday morning, will set off one of the most intense leadership scrambles in modern Congressional GOP politics. Second in line is House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.), who is widely expected to serve as the next speaker. But there is serious unrest in the House Republican ranks, as a small clutch of conservatives have continuously clashed with more establishment Republican types. But it is unclear if any of these figures can win a leadership election.
Of course, the easy answer to the hard question in the title of this post is "it depends." As regular readers know, the younger, more conservative and libertarian-leaning members of Congress within the GOP have generally been more supportive of federal sentencing reform than older establishment GOP officials. Thus, I think the prospects for federal sentencing reform could grow a bit brighter with new blood in the speaker seat.
Then again, any power struggle for leadership positions in the House is almost sure to take time and attention away from other legislative duties. And diverted attention likely means any existing and future federal sentencing reform bills will have a hard time getting to and through a full vote in the House (and perhaps also the Senate).
September 25, 2015 at 10:14 AM | Permalink
Comments
The Congress will grind to a halt. Forget about sentencing reform. A Great Depression is coming.
Posted by: Jack Mehoff | Sep 26, 2015 2:12:54 PM
It is less who is Speaker than what rules the House will follow. If the fall of Boehner means that the next Speaker will only allow a bill to come to a vote if it has 218 Republican votes, then nothing substantive will get done this Congress. If the new Speaker is willing to allow 40-50 Republicans to vote no and rely on Democratic votes to pass legislation (what got Boehner in trouble), then something might happen.
Posted by: tmm | Sep 26, 2015 7:03:12 PM