« Is the "don't blame the drug war for mass incarceration" counter-narrative problematically incomplete? | Main | New papers looking closely (and differently) at offender-based sentencing considerations »
September 29, 2015
Long-awaited bipartisan federal criminal justice reform bill to emerge from Senate this week
A helpful reader alerted me to this notable new NPR story headlined "Bipartisan Criminal-Justice Overhaul Proposal Expected As Soon As Thursday." Here are the details:
A bipartisan group of senators on the Judiciary Committee is preparing to unveil a criminal-justice overhaul proposal as early as Thursday, two sources familiar with the deal told NPR. The plan follows months of behind-the-scenes work by the staffs of Sen. Charles Grassley, the Iowa Republican who chairs the committee, and several other lawmakers representing both political parties.
Senior members of the Obama administration, including the second-in-command at the Justice Department, also have been nudging senators on the sentencing plan, viewing the proposal as one of the capstones of a legacy on criminal-justice issues for this president. Barack Obama famously became the first sitting president to visit a prison in July.
An unusual left-right coalition formed earlier this year to drive action in Congress and in state houses across the country. The Coalition for Public Safety, which includes Koch Industries, the American Civil Liberties Union and others, is said to support the Senate plan, as well, a third source said.
The proposal will not go as far as some reform advocates may like, the sources say. For instance, the plan would create some tough new mandatory minimum sentences, after pressing from Grassley. It stitches together proposals that would allow inmates to earn credits to leave prison early if they complete educational and treatment programs and pose a relatively low risk to public safety along with language that would give judges some more discretion when sentencing non-violent offenders....
Despite the optimism among advocates and lawmakers, it's unclear whether the full Senate has the time to act before the presidential election intensifies. In the House, meanwhile, Reps. Bobby Scott, D-Va., and James Sensenbrenner, R-Wis., are pressing their own legislation, known as the SAFE Justice Act. The two leaders of the House Judiciary Committee, Chairman Bob Goodlatte, R-Va., and John Conyers, D-Mich., are writing their own bills, staff members said.
I am giddy with anticipation to see the specifics of this bill and I am cautiously hopeful that all the time spent working through the details will greatly increase the likelihood that a bill actually makes it through the Senate and perhaps all the way to the desk of Prez Obama. As I have long said in this space and others, hopeful visions of "the best" possible reform should not stand in the way of any "good" reform that has a real chance of becoming law. And since just about any reform emerging from a bipartisan deal is likely to have good elements, I am extra hopeful that this news means we getting ever closer to an improvement of existing federal sentencing law and policy.
September 29, 2015 at 07:27 PM | Permalink
Comments
Doug,
Like you I too believe that there will be elements of good in any reform bill passed. The question in my mind is whether there will be any net gain. Already this smacks of political horsetrading--which might make smart politics but rarely makes smart policy.
Sometimes it is better to walk away from a deal that only moves the chairs around.
Posted by: Daniel | Sep 29, 2015 7:45:48 PM
We know a couple of things before it is available.
It was written by lawyers.
Crime victims interests will be carpet bombed.
It will generate massive amounts of lawyer government make work jobs.
Posted by: Supremacy Claus | Sep 29, 2015 11:35:05 PM
Long pass time for a change, Enough is Enough...Stop the Insanity!!! Major Reform is needed and retroactive with M/M long sentences that have become major sources of abuse, torture, neglect,and just plain injustice.
Posted by: Flo PAPA | Sep 30, 2015 9:14:50 AM