« A year after denial, Henry Montgomery (of Montgomery v. Louisiana) to get parole reconsideration by parole board | Main | "Are Collateral Consequences Deserved?" »

January 28, 2019

"Federal criminal justice reform is now law: What comes next?"

The title of this post is the headline of this recent Hill commentary authored by Tim Head, the executive director of the Faith & Freedom Coalition. Here are excerpts:

Now that the FIRST STEP Act is law, the question becomes what is next at the federal level and what policy innovations can state governments develop to continue the national momentum toward a more efficient and effective justice system.

The next order of business for implementation of federal reform is for the U.S. Senate to confirm William Barr as Attorney General of the United States.  As Attorney General, Barr and his appointed lieutenants would be responsible for selecting a new director for the federal Bureau of Prisons and ensuring that the Bureau accurately administers the codified risk assessment system for low-level, non-violent offenders who are eligible for release, and provide these inmates with the programs to help them safely and successfully re-enter society upon their release.

While the sentencing reforms contained in the FIRST STEP Act were secondary to the prison reforms that are to be administered by the Department of Justice, further sentencing improvements are possible through the U.S. Sentencing Commission.  The independent Sentencing Commission issues guidelines for sentencing in all federal criminal cases.

Today, the Commission lacks a quorum to function in its duties to administer federal sentencing laws.  The acting chair, Judge William Pryor of the Eleventh Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals is currently awaiting renomination by the White House and confirmation by the Senate.  By once again making Judge Pryor the chair of the commission, the Trump administration and the Senate can follow through on the promises made by the passage of the FIRST STEP Act.

These nominations are necessary to ensure proper implementation of the provisions contained in the FIRST STEP Act and are essential to ensure the reforms championed by President Trump and reform leaders in Congress are delivered. However, despite the “ah-hah” moment that the federal government realized with the passage of the FIRST STEP Act, states must continue to lead the way as they have done for the past decade.

Many states have joined the chorus of justice reform begun by Texas, Georgia and South Carolina.  Ohio recently passed legislation to seal certain low-level criminal records and promote drug and alcohol treatment programs as alternatives to prison.  In Pennsylvania, Governor Tom Wolf (D) signed the nation’s first "Clean Slate” law to seal records of offenders convicted of low-level, nonviolent misdemeanor offenses who do not incur further criminal charges over ten years.

Pennsylvania also removed one of the most challenging barriers for ex-offenders to safely and successfully re-enter society by eliminating automatic suspensions of driver’s licenses for low-level offenses.  Kentucky Governor Matt Bevin and the state legislature enacted reforms to make it possible for former low-level inmates to attain occupational permits so they can work to support themselves and their families and turn away from crime.

The momentum achieved by state-level reforms made the FIRST STEP Act possible at the federal level.  States that have been slow to move have example after example of successful improvements in other states.  And now, in light of what President Trump and Congress have done to make the justice system more efficient and effective, it is vital to continue the cycle of reform across the country which has made our communities safer and restored lives at all levels.

January 28, 2019 at 07:28 PM | Permalink


Automatic suspension of DL? For any offense? That's just absurd. Punitiveness run amok.

Posted by: Fat Bastard | Jan 29, 2019 12:10:47 PM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB