« Via 5-4 vote, SCOTUS reverses lower court stay of Alabama execution ... but does so too late for Alabama to carry out execution | Main | "Introducing Disruptive Technology to Criminal Sanctions: Punishment by Computer Monitoring to Enhance Sentencing Fairness and Efficiency" »

April 12, 2019

Spotlighting concerns about organization tasked with helping Justice Department develop and implement risk and needs assessment tools under FIRST STEP Act

As reported here on Monday, this week the Department of Justice finally got around to announced the selection of the Hudson Institute as the host the Independent Review Committee required by the FIRST STEP Act to help DOJ develop and implement the Act's risk and needs assessment tools and recidivism reduction programs.  Various folks, including members of Congress, have expressed various concerns about this pick, and this new Mother Jones article effectively reviews why.  The article is headlined "Trump Keeps Celebrating Prison Reform. His Administration’s Latest Move Could Sabotage It," and is worth reading in full.  Here are excerpts (with links from the original):

Now lawmakers of both parties who backed the First Step Act are alarmed at the Justice Department’s latest move, and at least two senators made clear their discomfort during a hearing on Wednesday.  “I’m a little bit worried that we just let a fox in the chicken coop here,” Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) said of the Hudson Institute during a confirmation hearing for deputy attorney general nominee Jeffrey Rosen.  “This is a think tank that has a point of view…They published an article entitled, ‘Why Trump Should Oppose Criminal-Justice Reform.’ This is the same agency that’s now been chosen by the Department of Justice and Trump administration to be part of this so-called independent review [committee] system.”

Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah) meanwhile described the institute as an “opponent of the First Step Act” and asked whether Rosen would choose another group to focus on the risk assessment tool if he were confirmed. (Rosen did not answer that part of the question but said he supported the First Step Act.)  “I don’t see a lot of good faith in implementing this law right now,” Lee said.  “And it’s become increasingly clear to me in the last few days that some Department of Justice officials at least don’t like the First Step Act, and they seem not to care that Congress passed this law and that President Trump signed this into law.”

The Hudson Institute, founded in 1961, is known for its work on national security and foreign policy, though it also focuses on economics and domestic policy.  For the First Step Act, it has announced six committee members so far who will develop the risk assessment program.  One of the members is its own chief operating officer, John Walters, who served as a drug czar in the Bush administration.  During his confirmation hearing for that position in 2001, some senators said they were concerned about his views on criminal justice: He had written it was a “great urban myth” that the country was imprisoning too many people for drug possession, and he had suggested that the disparity between crack and powder cocaine sentences was merely a “perceived racial injustice,” implying no real racial discrimination was at play.  In 2015, after he joined the Hudson Institute, he wrote that the concept of “mass incarceration” was also a myth, and that “the great majority of federal prisoners appear to be incarcerated because they were, properly, adjudged guilty and justly sentenced.”  These views appear to be in direct conflict with changes in the First Step Act, including reforms to ease some mandatory minimum sentences and retroactively reduce sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine offenses. (That said, a Hudson Institute spokesperson says Walters has publicly endorsed reforms to crack sentencing since the early 2000s.)

Some of many prior related posts:

April 12, 2019 at 03:08 PM | Permalink


Did you ever consider teaming up with the "Innocence Project" or consulting with inmates that have been found innocent?
The old saying, take a walk in my shoes still has meaning!

Posted by: LC in Texas | Apr 13, 2019 7:30:54 PM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB