« Exciting DEPC and OJPC sentencing project: "Drafting Contest: An Ohio 'Second Look' Statute" | Main | "While jails drastically cut populations, state prisons have released almost no one" »

May 1, 2020

AG Barr deceptively suggests 5000 inmates have been moved from federal prison to home confinement, while BOP now reports moving "1,959 inmates"

Attorney General William Barr participated today in a nationwide #AskTheAG Q&A session via Twitter.  I was glad to see him participating in this forum and also glad to see he answered this question posed by Representative Bobby RushL

Q: Why does DOJ/BOP refuse to release prisoners who pose ZERO threat to society despite the increasing number of deaths happening in federal prisons due to COVID-19? 

AG Barr's answer to this question (second in thread), which runs about about 90 seconds, includes an interesting (and problematic) statement about what has been done to date by DOJ and BOP.  AG Barr explains that, in the CARES Act, Congress broadened DOJ discretion to move more inmates out of prison and into home confinement, and then he says: "We have been using that discretion aggressively, right now we have just short of 5000 in home confinement and we have another 1000 in the pipeline."

In the context of both the question and the rest of AG Barr's answer, this statement seems like a straight-forward assertion that because of coronavirus concerns, DOJ/BOP has already moved nearly 5000 persons out of federal prison and into home confinement (with 1000 more on the way).  Indeed, early media reports here and here and here about this statement have understood and reported what AG Barr said as an indication that 5000 inmates have be relocated from prison to home confinement due to the coronavirus crisis. 

But I do not think that suggestion matches with BOP reality because BOP's own COVID-19 Update page, as of the afternoon of May 1, reports (emphasis added):

Since the release of the Attorney General's original memo to the Bureau of Prisons on March 26, 2020 instructing us to prioritize home confinement as an appropriate response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the BOP has placed an additional 1,959 inmates on home confinement.

It is my guess that the Attorney General, when stating "right now we have just short of 5000 in home confinement," was actually referencing the total number of persons on home confinement, thousands of which were already serving their sentences at home before COVID came along.  According to the BOP, which has been reporting these data on an on-going basis for weeks, AG Barr inflated the real numbers here by 150% to suggest doing a whole lot more than BOP actually is.  (Notably, the real BOP numbers would reflect a movement of just over 1% of the federal prison population into home confinement; even AG Barr's total inflated numbers would still only get us to just over 3% of the federal prison population moved into home confinement.  And, critically, current data show there are still well over 10,000 federal prisoners over age 60 and surely many more with COVID vulnerabilities.) 

It strikes me as extremely deceptive and problematic that the AG in this context used phrasing to create the misimpression that thousands more persons were being moved to home confinement due to COVID than BOP's own website reports.  And I suspect he did this not only to create the misimpression that DOJ/BOP has been taking major steps in this arena, but also to bolster arguments being made by prosecutors in courtrooms around the country that judges ought to trust how BOP is handling the COVID crisis and not grant requests from persons in prison for relief from dangerous prison conditions.

UPDATE: I am disappointed, but not surprised, to see this New York Times piece about AG Barr's comments reiterating the inaccuracy in the AG's deceptive statement:  "Mr. Barr said that the bureau took 'the health and safety of our inmates very seriously,' and had moved to release nearly 5,000 prisoners to home confinement and had another 1,000 in the pipeline."    Similarly, Fox News repeated this misrepresentation in its story: "Barr replied to the Democratic congressman that the Department of Justice had used its authority under the First Step Act to move nearly 5,000 prisoners who were considered vulnerable to COVID-19 from incarceration to home confinement, and had another 1,000 'in the pipeline' to be moved." 

Dare I say it: FAKE NEWS, thanks to the Attorney General mostly, but also thanks to media not following up properly with a check of the official BOP data! 

In any event, I would now suggest advocates try to turn the lemon-sour deception of AG Barr into decarceration lemonade by arguing, in every venue, that the AG's comments have served to create a short-tern goal of getting a full 6000 COVID-vulnerable prisoners who were incarcerated in March into home confinement before the end of May.

May 1, 2020 at 03:20 PM | Permalink

Comments

Prof, you write, "It strikes me as extremely deceptive and problematic that the AG in this context used phrasing to create the misimpression that thousands more persons were being moved to home confinement due to COVID than BOP's own website reports."

No surprise ? By the way, remember when Trump sent investigators to Hawaii to look into the "mystery" surrounding Obama's birth? And remebber Trump's annoucning that the investigators had discovered "astoudning" things, which Trump would soon release to the public? Well, we're still waiting...and waiting....and waiting.

Posted by: Michael R. Levine | May 3, 2020 10:41:47 AM

The US Government puts people in prison that are truly innocent and they don't care as long as they win their case.They entrap people and all kinds of cruel things but when they could help get them out, all they think about is money. All elderly prisoner's should be released that pose no threat.There are so many prisoner's in custody that have fought for their Country and the Government is letting them down. Please let them out...

Posted by: Janice Bishop | Jun 17, 2020 7:21:50 AM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB