« Two more great reports from NYU Center reviewing state clemency history in New York and Connecticut | Main | After DC Circuit denies en banc review, wondering what might be next for litigation over federal lethal injection plans »

May 17, 2020

"The Prisoner Trade"

The title of this post is the title of this new article by Emma Kaufman recently posted to SSRN.  Here is its abstract:

It is tempting to assume that the United States has fifty distinct state prison systems.  For a time, that assumption was correct.  In the late twentieth century, however, states began to swap prisoners and to outsource punishment to their neighbors.  Today, prisoners have no right to be incarcerated in the state where they were convicted, and prison officials may trade prisoners — either for money or for other prisoners — across state lines.

Interstate prison transfers raise questions about the scope of states’ authority to punish, the purpose of criminal law, and the possibilities of prison reform.  Yet apart from prisoners and their families, few people know that prisoners can be shipped between states.  Because information on prisoners is so hard to obtain, scholars, lawyers, lawmakers, and even the judges who impose prison sentences often have no idea where prisoners are held.

Drawing on a wide range of primary sources, including data uncovered through open records requests to all fifty states, this Article offers the first comprehensive account of the prisoner trade.  It demonstrates that states have far more authority than one might expect to share and sell prisoners.  It reveals that certain states rely on transfers to offset the actual and political costs of their prosecution policies.  And it critiques the pathologies of interstate punishment, arguing that courts should require consent before a prisoner can be sent outside the polity whose laws he has transgressed.

May 17, 2020 at 11:47 AM | Permalink


Shipping prisoners from one state to another also raises security concerns if prisoners, while in transit, decide to rebel against their transfer by attempting to assault the driver or take some of the guards on the vehicles as hostages. Have prosecutors thought about this?

Posted by: William Delzell | May 18, 2020 9:22:44 AM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB