« "Visualizing the racial disparities in mass incarceration" | Main | Federal prison population, per BOP reporting, now down to 157,862 »

July 29, 2020

"Will The Reckoning Over Racist Names Include These Prisons?"

The question in the title of this post is the headline of this interesting Marshall Project piece.  Here is a snippet:

While the killing of George Floyd has galvanized support for tearing down statues, renaming sports teams and otherwise removing markers of a (more) racist past, the renewed push for change hasn’t really touched the nation’s prison system. But some say it should. Across the country, dozens of prisons take their names from racists, Confederates, plantations, segregationists, and owners of slaves. “Symbols of hate encourage hate, so it has been time to remove the celebration of figures whose fame is predicated on the pain and torture of Black people,” said DeRay McKesson, a civil rights activist and podcast host.

Some candidates for new names might be prisons on former plantations. In Arkansas, the Cummins Unit—now home to the state’s death chamber—was once known as the Cummins plantation (though it’s not clear if the namesake owned slaves). In North Carolina, Caledonia Correctional Institution is on the site of Caledonia Plantation, so named as a nostalgic homage to the Roman word for Scotland....

James E. Ferguson — namesake of the notoriously violent Ferguson Unit [in Texas near Huntsville — was a governor in the 1910s who was also an anti-Semite and at one point told the Texas Rangers he would use his pardoning power if any of them were ever charged with murder for their bloody campaigns against Mexicans, according to Monica Muñoz Martinez, historian and author of “The Injustice Never Leaves You.” Ferguson got forced out of office early when he was indicted and then impeached. Afterward, he was replaced by William P. Hobby, a staunch segregationist who opposed labor rights and once defended the beating of an NAACP official visiting the state to discuss anti-lynching legislation. Hobby, too, has a prison named after him....

To many experts, the idea of changing prison names feels a bit like putting lipstick on a pig: No matter what you call it, a prison is still a prison. It still holds people who are not free. They are still disproportionately Black and brown. “If you are talking about the inhumanity, the daily violence these prisons perform, then who these prisons are named after is useful in understanding that,” Martinez said. “But what would it do to name it after somebody inspiring? It’s still a symbol of oppression.”

But to Anthony Graves, a Texas man who spent 12 years on death row after he was wrongfully convicted of capital murder, the racist names are a “slap in the face of the justice system itself.” New names could be a powerful signal of new priorities. “At the end of the day the mentality in these prisons is still, ‘This is my plantation and you are my slaves,’” he said. “To change that we have to start somewhere and maybe if we change the name we can start to change the culture.”

July 29, 2020 at 03:39 PM | Permalink


Who would want a prison named after them anyway!

Posted by: Jason | Jul 29, 2020 11:39:31 PM

Don't forget courthouses. The Richard b. Russell Building in Atlanta is named after a die hard segregationist. it's a disgrace.

Posted by: defendergirl | Jul 30, 2020 12:44:53 PM

"While the killing of George Floyd has galvanized support for..."

Since Floyd's autopsy clearly shows he was not killed in any way, an article that begins with the above words, does not merit any value at all.

Floyd was not killed. He died from taking too many drugs.

And the idea that naming anything after a person in US history is racist or even that a person who was for slavery was a racist (seeing as how slavery was and still is a practice that has nothing whatsoever to do with race) is preposterous. No one now or even then back in history is "hurt" by the name of an institution or a statue.

Please stop featuring these deeply flawed--and yes, racist, because that's what they are--propaganda screeds. They are simply propaganda screeds.

Posted by: restless94110 | Jul 30, 2020 11:39:45 PM

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB