« Senators Durbin and Grassley re-introduce "Prohibiting Punishment of Acquitted Conduct Act" | Main | Prisons as first frontier of the welfare state in The Last Frontier state »

March 8, 2021

"Taking Restorative Justice Seriously"

The title of this post is the title of this notable recent acticle authored by Adriaan Lanni and now available via SSRN. Here is its abstract:

Those seeking to reduce mass incarceration have increasingly pointed to restorative justice — an approach that typically brings those affected by a criminal offense together in an attempt to address the harm caused by the offense rather than to mete out punishment.  This Article is an attempt to think seriously about incorporating restorative justice throughout the criminal legal system.

For restorative justice proponents, expanding these practices raises a host of questions: Does the opportunity to alleviate mass incarceration justify collaboration with a deeply flawed criminal legal system?  Will the threat of criminal prosecution destroy the voluntariness and sincerity that is essential for a successful restorative process?  Can restorative justice be successfully used in cases where the victim cannot participate or there is no identifiable victim, as in drug offenses?  Will the process be coopted by bureaucratic impulses?  Restorative justice skeptics may ask whether applying a restorative approach to the most serious crimes will jeopardize the deterrent value of criminal law and lead to outcomes that are vastly disproportionate.  Those both inside and outside the movement will ask whether restorative justice can be implemented in a way that protects defendants’ procedural rights and is racially equitable.

I explore the choices and trade-offs that would be involved in expanding restorative justice to significantly reduce incarceration.  I argue that restorative justice can be expanded without significant adverse impacts on due process, racial equity, and proportionality.  At the same time, vastly expanding restorative justice entails compromising some key features of restorative justice.  I suggest that the disadvantages of expansion are significant, but are outweighed by the moral imperative to experiment with alternatives to mass incarceration.

March 8, 2021 at 10:41 AM | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB