« "Who Controls Criminal Law? Racial Threat and the Adoption of State Sentencing Law, 1975 to 2012" | Main | Tenth Circuit issues another notable ruling on federal compassionate release authority after the FIRST STEP Act »

April 1, 2021

CCJ's National Commission on COVID-19 and Criminal Justice releases "Impact Report: COVID-19 Testing in State Prisons"

noted here some months ago that the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ) had launched an important, timely and impressive new commission titled the "National Commission on COVID-19 and Criminal Justice" and headed by two former US Attorneys General.  That commission has already helped produce a number of important works (examples here and here and here), and I see that it released today this notable new report on COVID testing in prisons.  Here are the highlights as set forth in the relatively short report (with emphasis in original):


+ As of February 16, 2021, one of every three prisoners in 32 states with available testing data tested positive for COVID-19 — more than four times the rate outside of prisons.  Additionally, the COVID-19 death rate inside prisons is more than three times the community rate.

+ There was substantial variation across state prison systems in testing rates. Of the 32 states, three had testing rates of 1,000 per 1,000 individuals incarcerated, or lower (less than one test per person), while six had rates of 10,000 or higher (10 or more tests per individual).

+ Higher testing rates and, in particular, mass testing, especially in states that implemented this strategy early in the pandemic, likely resulted in lower rates of COVID-19 mortality behind bars. It is possible that early detection of coronavirus infections led to more and better prevention and treatment measures that improved outcomes.

  • States with lower disparities between prison and community death rates tested prison residents at rates that were nearly double those of states with higher prison/community disparities.  Positivity rates for lower-disparity states were almost half as high.
  • States that did not use a mass-testing strategy for their incarcerated populations had COVID-19 death rates among incarcerated people that were nearly eight times the death rate for non-incarcerated populations similar in age, gender, and race/ethnicity.  This disparity was cut in half in states that implemented a mass testing strategy.

+ Four states that carried out mass testing — Colorado, Connecticut, Michigan, and Vermont — varied in their specific protocols but had relatively good COVID-19 outcomes compared to other state prison systems.

+ Taken together, the evidence suggests that more testing, early testing, and early mass testing may have been strategies that helped states achieve lower rates of COVID-19 mortality behind bars, although causality cannot be conclusively established.

April 1, 2021 at 01:43 PM | Permalink


Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB