« "The President’s Conditional Pardon Power" | Main | Lots of GVRs (especially to Fifth Circuit) on latest SCOTUS order list »

June 20, 2021

Scouting the state judge who will sentence Derek Chauvin for murdering George Floyd

This new NBC News article, headlined "Derek Chauvin sentencing thrusts Minnesota Judge Peter Cahill back into spotlight," provides something of a scouting report on the judge who is scheduled to  sentence Derek Chauvin later this week.  Here are excerpts:

A Minnesota judge who, former colleagues and friends say, has no penchant for publicity will again find himself in the media spotlight this week when he sentences the former Minneapolis police officer convicted of murder in the death of George Floyd.

Judge Peter Cahill, who has served on the bench in Hennepin County for 14 years, could sentence Derek Chauvin to as little as probation, an outcome requested by his attorney, or more than the 30-year punishment favored by prosecutors.

In interviews, people who know Cahill and cases he has overseen say he is likely to land somewhere in the middle.  They said he is a fair judge, though there is no guarantee he will mete out a punishment that will make either side entirely happy.  "He's been both a prosecutor and a defense attorney," said Craig Cascarano, 72, a Minneapolis lawyer in private practice who met Cahill at the Hennepin County Public Defender's Office when Cahill was a law clerk.  "So he understands what it's like to do both jobs. And he tries very hard to do the right thing."...

Cahill will sentence Chauvin on Friday, about two months after he oversaw the trial that ended in his conviction on charges of second- and third-degree murder, as well as second-degree manslaughter.  Cahill has paved the way for Chauvin's punishment to be up to double the 15 years at the top of the range recommended under state guidelines, having ruled in May that there were four aggravating factors in Floyd's death....

From 2008, the year he was elected to the bench, through January, Cahill has sentenced six people convicted of second-degree murder to prison.  They received terms ranging from 12.5 years to 40 years.

In Cahill's most recent case of sentencing on unintentional second-degree murder — the most serious charge on which Chauvin was convicted — he handed down a punishment of 15 years.  In that case, Matthew Witt pleaded guilty in January 2020 to unintentional second-degree murder for beating his mother to death and to first-degree assault for violently attacking his father July 24, 2019, authorities said.  He received an additional seven years for the latter charge.

Prior related posts:

June 20, 2021 at 05:51 PM | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB