« Notable new ACLU report on prison labor in the United States | Main | "Letting Offenders Choose Their Punishment?" »
June 16, 2022
New issue of Brooklyn Law Review examines "The Role of the 'Victim' in the Criminal Legal System"
I just recently came across online the latest issue of the Brooklyn Law Review, and it is now high on my summer reading list. The abstract of the Foreword to the issue, penned by Kate Mogulescu, provides this context:
On September 24, 2021, the Brooklyn Law Review brought together scholars looking at the role of the “victim” in the criminal legal system. Of consideration were the following questions: Who is labeled a victim and how does that impact outcomes and process? Where does the issue of victimization emerge, how is it received and what should the system’s response be? Who gets a voice? And when? Does the existing victim-offender binary further exacerbate a criminal legal system build on misogyny, xenophobia, and white supremacy? The series of articles and essays that make up this issue reflect the symposium’s multidimensional discussion and interrogate the way the legal system recognizes, or fails to recognize, those who have experienced harm.
And here is a list of all the articles in this issue:
Giving Meaning to the Apostrophe in Victim[’]s Rights by Margaret Garvin
Should Victims’ Views Influence Prosecutors’ Decisions? by Bruce A. Green and Brandon P. Ruben
Blame the Victim: How Mistreatment by the State Is Used to Legitimize Police Violence by Tamara Rice Lave
Protecting the Constitution While Protecting Victims: Challenges to Pro Se Cross-Examination by Katharine L. Manning
Defense Counsel’s Cross Purposes: Prior Conviction Impeachment of Prosecution Witnesses by Anna Roberts
What Are Victim Impact Statements For? by Susan A. Bandes
Parole, Victim Impact Evidence, and Race by Alexis Karteron
Rotten Social Background and Mass Incarceration: Who Is a Victim? by Steven Zeidman
The Victim/Offender Overlap and Criminal System Reform by Cynthia Godsoe
June 16, 2022 at 01:32 AM | Permalink
Comments
"Does the existing victim-offender binary further exacerbate a criminal legal system build on misogyny, xenophobia, and white supremacy?"
For sure, the problem is never the fellow who puts a revolver in your ear to get your wallet, it's only "a criminal legal system build [sic] on misogyny, xenophobia, and white supremacy?"
This entry looked interesting until I saw that. Now I know to expect just the usual Amerika Stinks tripe I always see out of these creeps. No thanks.
Posted by: Bill Otis | Jun 16, 2022 10:15:24 AM
Bill,
Notice that there is no evidence supporting the claim the system is based on, “misogyny, xenophobia, and white supremacy?” It appears the entire issue is based on a premise they just assume.
Not exactly a good way to start an issue in a “scholarly” journal.
Posted by: TarlsQtr | Jun 16, 2022 2:51:33 PM
TarlsQtr --
It's unfortunate, indeed it's tragic, that the life of academic inquiry has been replaced by enforced conformity to the Woke line, with no curiosity and even less dissent.
Posted by: Bill Otis | Jun 16, 2022 3:19:04 PM