« "Federal Sentencing of Illegal Reentry: The Impact of The 2016 Guideline Amendment" | Main | "Cruel and Unusual Youth Confinement" »
July 20, 2022
Council on Criminal Justice releases "Long Sentences by the Numbers"
In this post a couple of month ago, I noted the formation of the Council of Criminal Justice's impressive Task Force on Long Sentences. Today, I was alerted to the release are this fascinating new resource from CCJ titled "Long Sentences by the Numbers." The full resource merits a deep dive, and here are excerpts:
Launched by the Council in Spring 2022, the Task Force on Long Sentences is assessing our nation’s use of long prison terms and formulating recommendations to advance safety and justice. This series of charts serves as a foundation for the deliberations of the group, a diverse set of experts from varied sectors of the criminal justice field and across the ideological spectrum.
The data below address three fundamental questions. Each provides a different perspective on the nature and extent of long prison sentences, which the Task Force defines as a court-imposed prison term of 10 years or more, independent of the time people actually serve.
- Admissions: What are the number and share of people admitted with a long prison sentence? Admissions data show changes in the frequency with which courts impose long sentences.
- Population: What is the size of the prison population serving long sentences, and what share of the total population do these individuals represent? Prison population data, based on a snapshot of people incarcerated at a moment in time (typically at year’s end), reveal how many people behind bars are serving long sentences.
- Releases: What are the number and share of people released from prison after serving a long sentence and how much time did they actually serve? Every jurisdiction has statutes and policies such as discretionary parole and credits for good behavior that permit people to be released prior to serving their maximum sentence. Release data enable us to discern how many people are released after having served 10 or more years, independent of the upper limit of their sentences.
[These data are drawn] from varying combinations of up to 29 state prison systems submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice's National Corrections Reporting Program (NCRP) from 2005 through 2019. Council researchers selected the states and time period because they offered the most complete and consistent set of relevant national-level data to describe basic trends in long sentences....
Key Takeaways
People with long sentences account for a relatively small share of state prison admissions and releases, but because they serve long periods, their numbers stack up over time. In 2019, 17% of people admitted to prison were sentenced to 10 years or more, and 3% of those released had served 10 years or more. At year-end, 57% of people in prison were serving a long prison sentence, up from 46% in 2005.
The length of time served by people sentenced to 10 years or more has grown. Between 2005 and 2019, the average amount of time served by this group increased from 9.7 years to 15.5 years.
The share of people convicted of a violent crime who received long sentences grew from 7% in 2005 to 10% in 2019. The percentage of people convicted of property and drug offenses who received long sentences remained stable, at 3% and 2%, respectively.
The shares of Black and White people receiving long sentences have grown over time and the gap between those shares has widened, from 1 percentage point in 2005 to 4 percentage points in 2019. When accounting for conviction offenses, Black people are more likely to receive long sentences for violent crimes while White people are for some property crimes. White people convicted of drug crimes were more likely than Black people to get a long sentence in 2005 but less likely by 2019.
Compared to other age groups, people aged 55 and over are the fastest-growing age group serving long sentences. Between 2005 and 2019, the share of people serving long sentences who were aged 55 and over grew from 8% to 20%.
Men are more likely than women to receive and serve a long sentence. On average, men are about 72% more likely to receive a long sentence and over three times more likely to serve a long sentence than women, mostly because men are convicted of more serious, violent crimes. Greater shares of both men (up 4%) and women (up 3%) received sentences of 10 years or more in 2019 than in 2005.
July 20, 2022 at 02:08 PM | Permalink
Comments
One additional stat that would interest me is prior record. When we were redoing our criminal code about a decade ago, the general consensus among people from both sides of the bar was that we should be shifting long sentences away from non-violent offenses to violent offenses and that repeat offenders deserved longer sentences than first time offenders. While the two sides might disagree on how long a "long sentence" should be, there was a consensus that -- to the extent that we wanted to incarcerate people -- it was violent repeat offenders that we wanted to incarcerate.
While there is no direct stat in the report on the issue of prior offense history, the age category may be a proxy for prior history. However, while that is a logical inference, there could be reasons other than prior history for the changes based on age.
Posted by: tmm | Jul 20, 2022 5:10:38 PM
I suspect that the increase in over-55 among those serving long sentences is simply because those people have already been serving their current sentence for many years. They may have only been charged once, at age 20, and been punished ever since for the "crime" of refusing to accept a plea bargain, to teach a lesson to accused people who are considering demanding a fair trial or other constitutional rights.
Posted by: Keith Lynch | Jul 21, 2022 7:33:20 AM