« GAO releases big report concluding "Bureau of Prisons Should Improve Efforts to Implement its Risk and Needs Assessment System" | Main | New OIG report provides "Capstone Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Response to the Coronavirus Disease" »
March 22, 2023
Convicted of felony murder as teen for police killing during burglary, LaKeith Smith gets sentence reduced to "only" 30 years in Alabama
A felony murder case from Alabama received some national media attention as a resentencing proceeding approached this week. That resentencing and its context are covered in this AP article headlined "Man sentenced to 30 years after police officer shot friend." Here are some of the details:
LaKeith Smith was 15 when a police officer shot and killed his friend when the teens were caught burglarizing homes in Alabama, but it is Smith who will spend decades in prison for his friend’s death. A judge on Tuesday sentenced Smith, now 24, to 30 years in prison — a reduction from the more than 50 years he originally received, but a blow to his family and advocates who argued he should not spend decades in prison for a killing he did not commit.
The new sentencing hearing was held after a judge ruled Smith’s original lawyer failed to present possible mitigating evidence about his home life and mental health. Circuit Judge Sibley Reynolds handed down the new sentence after a lengthy court hearing. Sibley gave Smith the same punishment he previously handed down — 30 years for the felony murder charge and 25 years for burglary and theft — but this time allowed the sentences to run concurrently, instead of stacked on top of one another.
“What he received today was not justice. It was clearly an over-sentence,” defense attorney Leroy Maxwell said after court. He said they will pursue an appeal. Maxwell said the case, which has garnered national attention because of Smith’s age and the sentence he received, is the “poster child” for the misuse of felony murder laws that allow someone to be charged for a killing during commission of a felony even if the death was unintentional.
The fatal shooting happened on Feb. 23, 2015, when Millbrook police officers responded to a call of a burglary in progress. A Millbrook police officer shot and killed 16-year-old A’Donte Washington when officers surprised the teens, local news outlets reported. A grand jury cleared the officer in the shooting. The surviving four teens were charged with felony murder. Three took a plea deal, and Smith went to trial.
The Elmore County courtroom, which sits across the highway from a state prison, erupted in angry shouts after the judge handed down the sentence, attorneys and others said. “He’s not a murderer. He doesn’t deserve 55 or 30 years,” Smith’s mother, Brontina Smith, said after court.
Maxwell argued LaKeith Smith was the least culpable of the teens because he was the youngest and there was no evidence he fired a gun. The judge heard testimony about Smith’s difficult home life, as well as a request from Washington’s father to let Smith go free. “They were kids, just kids. I don’t condone them going to somebody’s house and whatever. Give them time for that. But the murder of my child? No,” Andre Washington said after court.
District Attorney CJ Robinson, who was the prosecutor in the case before being elected as district attorney, said the sentence is within the allowed guidelines. “There are no winners here. Never have been (in) this case,” Robinson said via text after court. He supported the new sentencing hearing for Smith, agreeing that Smith’s original trial lawyer did an inadequate job at sentencing....
The case has put a spotlight on the state’s felony murder law, a legal doctrine that holds someone liable for murder if they participate in a felony, such as a robbery, that results in someone’s death. Most states have felony murder laws, but rules vary on their use. According to a 2022 report by the Sentencing Project, a group advocating against mass incarceration, 14 states allow people engaged in a felony to be convicted of felony murder for a killing committed by a third party if it can be characterized as a foreseeable result of their action.
Additional national media coverage of this case include the following:
From The Marshall Project, "New Scrutiny on Murder Charges Against People Who Don’t Actually Kill: The U.S. is the only country that still uses the 'felony murder' legal doctrine."
From Mother Jones, "Police Killed His Friend and Blamed Him. He Got 65 Years in Prison. He Was 15.: A cop took an Alabama teen’s life, but LaKeith Smith took the charge. His big mistake: wanting a trial."
March 22, 2023 at 03:53 PM | Permalink
Comments
Another Alabama felony murder case is even crazier than the one you wrote about. Deputy Sheriff Vicki White helped inmate Casey White (not related to her by blood or law) escape from jail. They apparently had a secret romantic relationship going on. They were on the run for 11 days, until the F.B.I. and police caught up with them in Indiana, and rammed their vehicle, knocking it on its side in a ditch. Vicki shot herself in the head with a pistol, as law enforcement closed in, committing suicide. In July 2022, Alabama indicted Casey White under the felony murder rule for her suicide death. There was no homicide at all. If the prosecutors pursue that case to trial, I hope the jury rebukes them and grants a defense verdict. I find the prosecution irrational.
Posted by: Jim Gormley | Mar 22, 2023 9:25:14 PM
30 years is virtually a life sentence, and no child should be tried as an adult. I would've sentenced that young man to 5 years time served and had him released that day. States should abolish the felony murder doctrine.
Posted by: Anon | Mar 23, 2023 8:58:01 AM
He committed a dangerous felony, and someone died. Thirty years sounds about right.
Posted by: federalist | Mar 23, 2023 10:39:38 AM
Wait. So if I (allegedly) commit a property crime, and a cop shoots and kills my (alleged) partner, I can be charged with that killing? That is absolutely insane. I mean, crazy.
Also, UCR categorizes burglary as a property offense.
Posted by: Spike Bradford | Mar 27, 2023 11:49:25 AM