« Should every state have a dedicated commission to receive complaints about prosecutors? | Main | "The Eighth Amendment's Time to Shine; Previewing Florida's Imminent Constitutional Crisis in Capital Punishment" »
May 8, 2023
Big spread in sentencing recommendations for Oath Keepers founder convicted of seditious conspiracy
As reported in this Washington Post piece, lawyers for "Stewart Rhodes urged a judge to sentence him to far less than the 25-year prison term sought by federal prosecutors for seditious conspiracy in the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol attack — asking for a penalty of time served or roughly 16 months behind bars — citing his military service and his founding and leadership of the right-wing extremist group Oath Keepers." Here is more:
In a Monday morning court filing, the attorneys emphasized that Rhodes volunteered for the Army in June 1983, completed Airborne school and was honorably discharged after suffering a spinal fracture in a low-altitude night jump in 1986. They emphasized his formation of the Oath Keepers in 2009, saying the group provided hurricane and other emergency relief, security in cities experiencing rioting, and protective details for VIPs during President Donald Trump’s rallies after the 2020 presidential election....
The defense filing came after a Friday evening memo by prosecutors asking a federal judge to sentence Rhodes to 25 years in prison and eight followers to at least 10 years behind bars, in the first punishments to be handed down to defendants convicted of seditious conspiracy in the Capitol riot.
Rhodes and the others face sentencing starting later this month. Rhodes was arrested in January 2022 and will have served roughly 16 months at that point....
Rhodes, a top deputy and four others were found guilty at trials in November and January of plotting to unleash political violence to prevent the Biden presidency, stashing a small arsenal of firearms at hotels in Northern Virginia before converging that afternoon at the East Capitol steps in military-style tactical gear. Three other co-defendants were convicted of obstructing Congress as it met to confirm the results of the 2020 election, among other crimes. Both top offenses are punishable by up to 20 years in prison, but prosecutors asked the court to stack sentences for Rhodes, citing among other things an enhanced terrorism penalty for actions intended to intimidate or coerce the government.
Prosecutors called for “swift and severe” punishment for Rhodes, saying his group’s actions went far beyond the scope and magnitude of any other Jan. 6 defendants sentenced so far. They said Rhodes exploited his public influence in the anti-government extremist movement and mobilized people for political violence after “spreading doubt about the presidential election and turning others against the government” because their preferred candidate did not win....
Mehta, Rhodes’s sentencing judge, has handed down the two longest punishments to Jan. 6 defendants so far, both for assaulting police: 14 years for Peter Schwartz of Kentucky, who attacked multiple officers and who has a long criminal history of 38 convictions, including multiple domestic and police assaults; and 10 years for Timothy Webster, a former New York City police officer who attacked a Capitol Police officer with a metal flagpole.
Rhodes’s attorneys said only those two men have been sentenced to more than eight years in Jan. 6 cases, attaching a 54-page government chart of sentences to a 16-page defense filing. About 200 of roughly 450 people sentenced have received no jail time, and more than half of the roughly 250 people who have been sentenced to prison received terms of less than two months.
Of 110 people sentenced for felonies, about 76 who pleaded guilty have been sentenced to an average of 33 months, and about 34 who were convicted at trial have been sentenced to an average of 44 months in prison, according to a separate Washington Post analysis.
The defense's 70-page sentencing filing is available at this link; the government's 183-page sentencing filing is available at this link.
May 8, 2023 at 11:29 PM | Permalink
Comments
Judge Anon sentences Rhodes to 20 years.
Posted by: anon | May 9, 2023 9:24:19 AM
It seems to me that Rhodes will end up with a Leadership Role sentencing enhancement, and possibly get additional time because of his legal knowledge, with a J.D. from Yale Law school. While he may not personally have done anything violent, the truth is he organized and fomented much of what transpired, and the violence of others should have been reasonably foreseeable to him, down to the possible hanging of V. P. Pence. I see him getting 20 to 25 years in the BOP.
Posted by: Jim Gormley | May 9, 2023 9:43:51 AM
20 years is an appropriate sentence for Rhodes. His lackeys should receive sentences between 5-10 years.
Posted by: Anon1 | May 10, 2023 12:38:21 AM
https://townhall.com/tipsheet/guybenson/2023/05/10/surprise-no-justice-no-peace-crowd-silent-on-murder-of-chicago-police-officer-n2623021
Funny how the newfound tough on crime crowd is strangely silent about a preventable murder of a cop.
Posted by: federalist | May 10, 2023 12:12:42 PM