« "Governor Kate Brown of Oregon's Historic Use of Clemency: Using Clemency Exactly as It Was Intended" | Main | Brennan Center releases "Myths and Realities: Prosecutors and Criminal Justice Reform" »
October 24, 2024
LA District Attorney announces that he will seek resentencing for the Menendez brothers
In this post from a few weeks ago, I noted the notable activity focused on possible resentencing of the Menendez brothers, who were convicted and sentenced to LWOP in California for the brutal 1989 killing of their parents. As reported in this Courthouse News Service piece, "LA District Attorney George Gascon announced Thursday that his office will be recommending that Erik and Lyle Menendez, who killed their parents in 1989, be resentenced." Here is more:
Erik and Lyle Menendez have been locked up for 35 years and are serving life sentences without the possibility of parole. They have claimed, both during their trials and subsequent to them, that they were sexually abused by their father Jose, and that the killings were done out of fear of continued abuse and a response to trauma. Their first trial, in 1993, ended in a mistrial, with the jury remaining deadlocked after a month of deliberations. After a second trial ...., the brothers were convicted. During both trials, prosecutors argued that Jose never abused his children, and that the brothers were motivated by money.
Recently, two new pieces of evidence have emerged that the brothers and their supporters say add weight to the claims of abuse. In 2023, a former member of the boy band Menudo, Roy Rossello, revealed that Jose Menendez, a record executive, drugged and raped him when Rossello was 14 years old. In addition to that, a letter purportedly written by Erik Menendez to his cousin in 1988, less than a year before the killings, was unearthed. In the letter, Menendez refers to the sexual abuse, writing, "Every night I stay up thinking he might come in."
Last year, the brothers filed a writ of habeas corpus, asking for the convictions to be thrown out based on new evidence, writing in a brief, "The new evidence not only shows that Jose Menendez was very much a violent and brutal man who would sexually abuse children, but it strongly suggests that — in fact — he was still abusing Erik Menendez as late as December 1988."
Last week, more than 20 of Erik and Lyle's family members met with Gascon, asking for the brothers to be resentenced under Marsy's Law, which gives crime victims a right to be heard prior to sentencing, as well as to have a say in resentencing hearings. Most of the extended Menendez family say 35 years in prison is more than enough for the brothers, now in their mid 50s, given the abuse they suffered at the hands of their father.
But not all family members agree. Milton Anderson, the 90-year-old surviving brother of Kitty, the brothers' mom, has spoken out against letting his sister's killers go free. "The 'new evidence' Gascón relies on cannot legally justify overturning the murder convictions of Erik and Lyle Menendez, who meticulously planned and executed the cold-blooded murders of both their parents," Anderson's attorney said in a written statement on Thursday. "They shot their mother, Kitty, reloading to ensure her death. The evidence remains overwhelmingly clear: the jury’s verdict was just, and the punishment fits the heinous crime."
I believe what is now California Penal Code § 1172.1 provides the legal basis and sets forth the legal standards for this kind of resentencing. I am not at all familiar with California resentencing practices, but I would guess that most judges follow the recommendations of prosecutors in these kinds of cases. But high-profile cases do not always follow the patterns of other cases, and it will be interesting to observe both the process and substance of this notable re-sentencing decision.
Prior recent releated post:
October 24, 2024 at 05:40 PM | Permalink