« Kim Kardashian advocates reconsidering Menendez brothers' LWOP sentences just as Los Angeles DA begins to do so | Main | Supreme Court grants cert on 13 new matters, with a few of possible interest for sentencing fans »

October 4, 2024

Making a robut case for robust legal representation for the incarcerated

Inquest has this notable new essay on a topic that I think merits a lot more attention, namely on the needs of the incarcerated for legal assistance.  The piece, authored by Jennifer Soble, is headlined "Lawyerless No More: Once a person is imprisoned, indigent defense stops. But the gravity of mass incarceration demands legal representation to the very end." I recommend the full essay, and here are some excerpts:

Some of the most vulnerable incarcerated people are denied counsel even in proceedings explicitly designed to help them because of their vulnerability. For example, although most states have a process for releasing incarcerated people who are terminally ill or disabled, almost no state provides lawyers to people who are eligible for this relief. Under these schemes, people eligible for medical release — many of whom are actively dying, or who live with paralysis, or who are experiencing severe cognitive decline — are expected to not only draft compelling legal filings, but are also expected to find their own housing and outside medical care, all from behind prison walls.... Expecting sick and dying incarcerated people to represent themselves undermines the very existence of these laws.

People who have suffered some of the most extreme harms of the criminal legal system—such as unconstitutional conviction or a sentence that is punctuated by a serious medical diagnosis—need improved access to legal assistance. But so do people who have been harmed in quieter, more common ways. Few people outside the system know that departments of corrections have enormous power to both lengthen and reduce sentences. Prison systems can award sentencing credit for participation in programs, in work assignments, and sometimes for no reason at all. Conversely, and perniciously, prison systems can take that sentencing credit away. Prison officials use this power capriciously, sometimes for significant incidents of misconduct, sometimes for technical rule violations, and sometimes for seemingly no reason at all.... Legal advocates can significantly move up an incarcerated person’s release date simply by advocating to ensure that they get the sentencing credit that they deserve, while ensuring that credit is not taken away illegally or unjustly....

For [some], the only hope of freedom [is] clemency, an act of “grace” that is usually held exclusively by state governors or, for those in the federal system, the president. Unencumbered by the burdensome rules that govern other forms of post-conviction relief, clemency has historically been a nimble vehicle to correct excessive sentences, unjust prosecutions, or criminal legal events that feel unjust years or decades after the fact. Governors and presidents used to grant clemency routinely, but it has become extremely rare since the 1950s.

However, while the use of clemency has plummeted, the number of people for whom clemency is the only possible avenue for freedom has skyrocketed. Before the 1970s, only seven states authorized life-without-parole sentences, and even those states rarely imposed them. Today every state allows life or virtual life sentences, and more than 200,000 people are currently serving these draconian prison terms. For them, clemency is the most probable path out of prison, and it is generally the only way for an incarcerated person to ask for release from prison based on their rehabilitation and personal growth.

There are many reasons that clemency applicants should have representation. Clemency is a slow process, subject to rules that feel both pointless and burdensome. Successfully navigating it often depends on receiving help from someone with experience in clemency. Still, the right to counsel does not extend to clemency, leaving most incarcerated people to pursue their only hope for freedom on their own.

October 4, 2024 at 08:31 AM | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment

In the body of your email, please indicate if you are a professor, student, prosecutor, defense attorney, etc. so I can gain a sense of who is reading my blog. Thank you, DAB